Today's post includes Picture Book reports! Yay!
Assigned to read 10 picture books and analyze them, I headed to the Provo Library and found these gems:
Piggy Pie Po by Audrey and Don Wood
Summary - This is a book about what Piggy likes to do, his accomplishments and his mischief as a young pig.
Analysis - The book rhymes but the rhythm was inconsistent and pulled me out of the story. Also, it may have just been more simple than I was expecting but there was no conflict and therefore, for me, little interest.
Ghosts For Breakfast by Stanley Todd Terasaki
Summary - Neighbors come to the door with a tale of a ghost encounter. The father takes his son to inspect these ghosts and they find out it was just a bunch of vegetables that had been hung out to dry.
Analysis - There is a bit of the rule of three here [three neighbors] but not consistently presented or ordered. It's not as generically relate-able as most ghost stories might seem because it's pretty heavy on the Japanese culture like the names they play on as well as the vegetables themselves. Things that many children would not recognize.
The Great Montefiasco by Colin Thompson
Summary - Montefiasco is a magician whose tricks all go wrong. People think he's hilarious but he wants to be taken seriously as a magician, not a comedian. After considering other options, he is persuaded to put up an assistant wanted add in the hope that one may improve his act. She doesn't. However, the two do fall in love and live happily ever after.
Analysis - I thought this was an intriguing idea with a fresh perspective on the theme of coming to terms with yourself and realizing that it's not so bad even if it's not what you envisioned. The MC doesn't really solve his own problem though because this lesson is taught to him by his assistant. Also, I felt the problems were solved disjointedly and in a hurried, unexplained manner towards the end of the book after the big build up. The illustrations were...interesting. I'm not sure if they added or detracted from the story.
The Secret Science Project That Almost Ate the School - by Judy Sierra
Summary - A girl needs a great science project to compete with her classmates'. She orders one online and when it arrives, ignores the instructions. Chaos and the consumption of family, friends, and even the teacher ensues. The girl remembers the directions in the nick of time and gets rid of the monster. She still has to clean up the mess left behind though.
Analysis - The book rhymed in a comfortable and fun way with the word choices. I enjoyed the story line as well as the conclusion and felt that it wasn't too preachy in having her clean up afterward.
Caps For Sale by Esphyr Slobodkina
Summary - A peddler has his caps stolen by monkeys while he naps. He tries all her can to get them back and eventually does so on accident.
Analysis - There is the use of repetition in the peddler's attempts to regain his caps. He does solve his own problem, if accidentally. The monkeys are an unexpected twist and what makes the story fun - kids love this idea of "monkey-see, monkey-do." The illustrations are simple and bright and fun to look at.
Those Darn Squirrels by Adam Rubin
Summary - An old lonely man tries to keep his one joy, birds, from flying south for the winter. Squirrels ruin all his plans and then the bids fly south anyway. The squirrels try to make the man happy again. In the end, he likes squirrels as well as birds and isn't so lonely anymore.
Analysis - There is a lot of repetition throughout the story. The funny subject and resolution make it an entertaining read though I had a hard time distinguishing who was supposed to be the MC, the old man or the squirrels.
Silvia and Bird by Catherine Rayner
Summary - A lonely dragon makes unexpected friends with a bird but she still feels left out because she's a dragon, not a bird. She decides to see if there are other dragons on the moon and the bird says it will go with her but it can't fly that high and the dragon has to rescue it. The dragon realizes she doesn't need to be with other dragons to be happy.
Analysis - The conflict here was too quickly and too simply solved for my taste. A case of enjoying the illustrations enough to pick it up and then being disappointed by the story itself.
Flora's Very Windy Day by Jeanne Birdsall
Summary - Flora thinks her little brother is a nuisance and decides to let the wind carry him away but she goes after him. The wind tries to find places for the brother to get left at but Flora declines all of them because she deems her brother not enough of something or unable to fill the positions suggested. She decides to bring him home after all.
Analysis - I loved the illustrations for this book. Absolutely delightful and, in my opinion, perfectly matched with the story. The MC solves her own problem [conflict with the brother and how she feels about him] through a series of events that give nice repetition and rhythm to the story.
Saying Goodbye to Lulu by Corinne Demas
Summary - A young girl dealing with the upcoming and then past loss of a beloved dog.
Analysis - There is a good deal of repetition in phrasing and scene order/presentation that gives a nice regularity to the structure. The topic isn't a very general one but it does a good job of portraying how such a loss can affect someone for a while, especially how the grieving process can be hard/different for children.
Iggy Peck Architect by Andrea Beaty
Summary - Iggy has had a passion for architecture since the age of 2. His teacher had a traumatic childhood experience that resulted in a hatred of buildings and architecture. She forbids Iggy to build anything in class. Disaster strikes on a class picnic and Iggy saves the day, enlightening his teacher to the virtues of architecture.
Analysis - The book rhymed which worked at times and not at others. There were clever end rhymes that fit but the internal rhymes were most often a stretch and didn't flow. Also, the rhythm would get comfortable and then be off track and then repeat the cycle. The MC solved several conflicts, the disaster as well as his teacher's dislike of architecture. Iggy is an industrious little boy!
----------------------
Author Visit
We had the pleasure of listening to Dean Hughes today on the virtues of brainstorming, character development, and outlining in the writing process. The development of plot and a sequence of events that actually made sense if something that I've struggled with and am currently struggling with so his advice was well timed indeed and I plan to attempt it in my own writing process.
What have I read?
Too many picture books to count, haha. Mostly all good though. It has been fun to go back to childhood and realize why I liked the books I liked.
I'm still keeping on with the Merlin series [just picked up the last one today!] and I've liked Merlin more and more as I watch him grow and learn about himself as well as the skills he's developing.
I also read Missing in Action by Dean Hughes in preparation for class today. I generally don't enjoy reading middle grade material as much as older or younger geared books but I really enjoyed this. It was fairly simple as the writing and plot went but the idea was intriguing as well as the various conflicts associated with it. Also, I was just excited about the setting because my fiance is from Delta, UT and now everyone in class will have heard of it! Haha
A quick blip of my own writing
I've gone through a couple rough patches lately but in the last day or so I've taken off again and I'm excited to see where I go.
The entire space was laced so deeply with magic that the air hummed with it, its power tangible as it brushed my arms in passing like a gentle breeze.
But the beauty of it was not for my eyes, as everything I saw reminded me of the aching absence of the powers I had once wielded. I knew that the spacious and furnished mansion and the plentiful gardens of the estate would only serve as permanent reminders of the hole that had lodged in my chest.
I realized that I was cursed to live without magic of my own, instead subject to and dependent entirely upon the magic of this place. Magic that I could instruct but which most definitely had a will and mind of its own.